We went diving on our honeymoon at Black Rock since we heard it is a great place to dive on Maui. We used In2Scuba Maui. we had an instructor named Ty. He showed us an awesome time. He pointed things out that we would have just swam past. I would recommend Black Rock for any level, and I would say ask for Ty from In2Scuba Maui to take you there. Thumbs up!!!