I've been diving here for about seven years, always in the daytime. But last trip we did it as a night dive from the Lahaina Divers boat. It's a fantastic daytime site, but it out-does itself at night. Tons of hunting conger eels, sponge crabs, lobsters, and we even saw a seahorse! I'd HIGHLY recommend doing this at night, but the shore entry would be gnarly in the dark.